Comments on: Pitch Arsenal Score Part Deux

This is great work. Kershaw @ 28 and Fernandez @ 33 suggest that something is missing and would love to see a follow up article which dives into why (command?). Considering that Kershaw is a true...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-894828

In reply to Rainmaker. Word.

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-894795

Just wanted to say this piece and Eno's work are really gifted stuff. Why I don't even think about paying for the F+ membership every year, just to support you guys. Really, phenomenal stuff here...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-887950

In reply to Gkfische. I took a stab at doing just what you are suggesting using a more primitive version ...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-881079

Hoping this comment gets seen despite being 3 weeks late to the party. It sounds like there is more fine-tuning work coming with the Pitch Arsenal Score, so my thought process here is more on the...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-880682

In reply to BonusCantos. It is awfully descriptive, but it provides breakout candidates based on the pitc...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-879099

This is really cool, but what exactly is it predictive of? What does it tell us about a player? I noticed it doesn't correlate well with ERA, for example. I was hoping something like that would b...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-878663

In reply to Daniel Schwartz. I understand that whiff/swing is more valuable than GB% but shouldn't an eli...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-878403

Is there a reason why you wouldn't use Whiffs Per Pitch instead of Whiffs Per Swing? Seems like Whiffs Per Swing would overstate the effectiveness of a pitch that doesn't generate alot of swings ...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-877867

Anibal Sanchez at 190. Did you just really fall off last year? I have to imagine his Rep Score for 2013 was much better with how high his K% and SwStr% were. Any particular reasons for drop off? ...

https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/pitch-arsenal-score-part-deux/#comment-877810